Nestled in the heart of East Hampton Village, 52 & 54 Fithian Lane presents a rare opportunity to own a private compound encompassing two single and separate properties. Set on a beautiful 0.60 +/- acre lot and surrounded by lush greenery, the homes sit directly across from protected nature trails. Perfectly configured with a main house designed for everyday living and a separate guest house ideal for hosting friends and family. The two homes offer gracious indoor living and inviting outdoor spaces that flows seamlessly. 52 Fithian Lane spans 1,676 +/- square feet featuring 4 bedrooms and 4 full bathrooms. The first floor welcomes you with a foyer leading to a cozy den with a fireplace and an ensuite bedroom. An additional bedroom and full bath sit just across the hall. The main level opens to a bright, airy living, dining, and kitchen area ideal for entertaining. Upstairs, you'll find an ensuite primary bedroom and a guest bedroom with a full bath. Outdoor living is enhanced by a large deck and grilling area. 52 Fithian Lane can also accommodate a separate pool, if desired. The home at 54 Fithian Lane offers 1,790 +/- square feet with 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. The first floor features a foyer that flows into a den with a fireplace and an open concept living, dining, and kitchen area extending to a spacious deck. A convenient first-floor ensuite bedroom complements the layout, while the second floor includes three more bedrooms and a full bath. Outside, a heated Gunite pool with spa, fire pit area, and an attached one-car garage create a serene retreat designed for relaxation and enjoyment. Just moments from Village shops, acclaimed restaurants, and pristine ocean beaches, this exceptional compound offers both convenience and tranquility. Your East Hampton sanctuary awaits.